Israeli Hostages & The Guthrie Case? No Comparison At All.

I'm sure the author thought this was a good premise in a way, but the reason the October 7, 2023 massacre of Israeli Jews by Hamas didn't get the same 24/7 attention that this Guthrie case is getting is precisely because those victims were Jewish! I don't remember constant coverage of the fact that Hamas thew babies into ovens like the Nazis did to the Jews in Auschwitz. And I can't possibly compare one missing woman to thousands of raped, brutalized, tortured, captured, and murdered Jews and a sadistic hostage saga that went on too long.  I doubt anyone else will make the "251 Nancys" connection either.

------------------------------------------------- 

Think of it as 251 Nancys. Maybe the interest and emotions around the Guthrie saga will help people to better understand what Israel went through, day after day, for two years.  

By Alan Newman 2-13-24

"Continuous reporting has filled television airways and made headlines in the United States about the kidnapping in Tucson, Ariz., of Nancy Guthrie, the mother of NBC News anchor Savannah Guthrie. Practically every news outlet has devoted time to each twist and turn of this story, which began on Feb. 1. It is a full-throated whodunit garnering viewers’ attention, and seemingly all have been caught up these past two weeks in worry and concern for this 84-year-old woman.

"A little more than two years ago, on Oct. 7, 2023, Israel was invaded by thousands of Palestinian terrorists from the Gaza Strip, led by Hamas. They invaded the southern border and proceeded to murder 1,200 people, injure some 2,000 others, and kidnap 251 men, women and children, dragging them into Gaza. The vicious perpetrators provided ample evidence of their ghoulish actions with their own GoPro cameras.

"Think of it as 251 Nancys.

"Israel went to war for the next two years—not just with Hamas in Gaza, but with Hezbollah in Lebanon, the Houthis in Yemen and Iran itself. On Oct. 13, 2025, the last of the living hostages returned to Israel. On Jan. 26, the last hostage body of Ron Gvili, 24, was brought home.

"In Hostages Square in Tel Aviv and throughout the Jewish Diaspora, the fate of the kidnapped became a gut-wrenching campaign. They were Israel’s 251 Nancys. Jews worldwide wore yellow ribbons and dog tags to show their solidarity. When visitors arrived at Ben-Gurion International Airport, photos of the captives stared back, their beautiful faces pleading for help. These same images were displayed in every corner across the country. The countdown to their return was tracked down to the second.

"Those rescued alive were celebrated as heroes, and for families whose relatives were buried, thousands attended funerals to grieve along with them.

"These same images of the hostages were desecrated on streets across the globe by the same keffiyeh-wearing mobs that rioted in support of the terrorists and against Israelis and Jews everywhere. At least, in the case of Nancy Guthrie, nobody is screaming for her people’s destruction and accusing her family of genocide.

"Yes, some of the hostages were Nancy Guthrie’s age. And there were many more young people. There were babies even—the redheaded Ariel and Kfir Bibas babies, who at 10 months and 4 years were just beginning their lives. The victims were light-skinned and dark-skinned. Some weren’t even Jewish, but Arab, Bedouin, Druze. Some weren’t Israeli, but guests and workers from abroad. Some had helped Palestinians in distress for years, some employed Gazans in their homes and fields, and some had been at a music festival, dancing and having a good time.

"In Israel, the societal resolve to never leave behind a hostage played out militarily, diplomatically and personally. After all, in just three degrees of separation, each kidnapped soul was a “family” member to every Israeli. In every synagogue, shop and neighborhood, the tragedy was front and center. Each rescue and resolution was important. So were each of the nearly 1,000 soldiers who died in battles and attacks waged on seven fronts.

"Thanks to America, and especially to U.S. President Donald Trump, working with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, the fighting in Gaza and throughout the region was mostly brought to a halt. With great celebration and relief, many hostages came home to their families, and the dead received a proper religious burial.

"Likely, the drama around Nancy Guthrie will soon be resolved. Maybe the interest and emotions around this saga will help people better understand what Israel went through, day after day, for 736 days."