As my mother used to say, "a word to the wise is sufficient". Those of us who followed all the warnings and advice after COVID began will be smart enough to heed the advice in this column. Those still in denial about COVID won't care about hantavirus, either.
--------------------------------------------
Opinion
The virus will not be another covid-19. But it does show how unprepared the world remains.
Washington Post, May 7, 2026 at 12:02 p.m. EDT
Lawrence O. Gostin is a distinguished professor at Georgetown University Law Center and directs the World Health Organization Collaborating Center on National and Global Health Law.
"The hantavirus outbreak aboard a cruise ship
off the coast of West Africa is not another covid-19. But it does raise
an unsettling concern: Six years after the pandemic exposed profound
failures in global cooperation, the world still struggles to manage
health threats coherently and collectively.
"Hantavirus is a severe and potentially lethal disease. Health officials have confirmed at least eight cases linked to the cruise outbreak, including three deaths and a patient who is critically ill.
"Transmission
of the disease is usually contained because people contract the virus
through exposure to infected rodent droppings, urine or saliva. But
authorities have identified a rare strain on this ship, originating in
the Andes region of South America, that can spread from person to
person, though typically only through close and prolonged contact.
Unlike coronavirus, which spreads efficiently through the air, Andean
hantavirus does not pose the same broad public risk. The danger is real,
but it remains limited.
"The
Hondius, a Dutch-flagged cruise ship, departed from Argentina on April
1, stopping at remote destinations in the South Atlantic. A large group
of passengers disembarked in the island of St. Helena after the first
death linked to the outbreak, later returning to their home countries.
The public health challenge is therefore no longer confined to one ship;
it now depends on whether national authorities can identify, monitor
and care for exposed travelers scattered across borders.
"By
the time the outbreak was widely reported, the cruise ship was off the
coast of Cape Verde in West Africa. Authorities there did not permit
general disembarkation, citing limited health-system capacity and
concern about exposing the local population. Spain has now agreed to receive the ship
in the Canary Islands. Several patients have been medically evacuated
to Europe, while other passengers will be repatriated to their home
countries.
"The result is a fragmented international response as passengers disperse across borders. The World Health Organization has recommended
active monitoring for 45 days, but it remains unclear whether
quarantine, isolation, testing and medical follow-up will be applied
consistently. What we do know is that hantavirus disease can progress
rapidly. If symptoms worsen and lung complications develop, the disease
can be lethal. There is no specific antiviral cure, but prompt,
intensive supportive care can be lifesaving.
"The
scene aboard the Hondius is uncomfortably familiar. Early in the covid
pandemic, cruise ships became floating symbols of international
paralysis. Passengers and crew were trapped aboard the Diamond Princess , quarantined off Japan in 2020, while governments argued over who was
responsible for them. Similar episodes unfolded around the world as
ports closed and countries denied entry, stranding travelers.
"Those failures were supposed to change the way the world responds to health emergencies. With strong U.S. support, the WHO adopted amendments
to its governing rules for cross-border disease threats. (I was on the
WHO review committee for those changes.) The reforms were intended to
strengthen transparency, improve coordination and better protect
travelers. The regulations also maintain a long-standing rule regarding
ships and aircraft: States should not deny vessels entry into ports or
prevent disembarkation, subject to limited public health exceptions
"The hantavirus outbreak is showing in real time that even strengthened
global health rules remain fragile. The WHO sought to coordinate the
response by issuing outbreak alerts, sharing information and
recommending monitoring of exposed passengers. But the agency lacks
authority to ensure compliance with international rules. It cannot
compel countries to permit disembarkation, harmonize quarantine policies
or share responsibility for exposed travelers.
"Cruise
ships uniquely expose the structural weaknesses of managing infectious
diseases aboard crowded vessels. They compress globalization into a
single floating environment: multinational passengers, private
operators, overlapping jurisdictions and long-distance travel. It is not
just hantavirus. Influenza, measles, norovirus and other infectious
pathogens can spread rapidly aboard crowded vessels. Once an outbreak
emerges at sea, responsibility quickly becomes diffuse and contested.
"The
political tensions surrounding the WHO further complicate the
situation. The reforms it adopted were intended to avoid another chaotic
maritime crisis. While the Biden administration strongly advocated for
new rules, President Donald Trump withdrew the United States
from the organization and formally rejected the amendments. As the
world confronts another cross-border outbreak, political support for
international cooperation is weakening.
"Meanwhile, negotiations over a new WHO pandemic agreement have stalled
in Geneva. Later this month, the World Health Assembly is expected to
give countries extension another year to complete that work. But the
world may not have the luxury of waiting if a more transmissible
pathogen emerges.
"Media
coverage of the outbreak risks overstating the epidemiological threat.
The world is not facing another covid-19. But the episode should shake
political leaders from their complacency. Most outbreaks — whether a
novel influenza, a coronavirus or a hemorrhagic fever like Ebola — never
become global catastrophes. But they reveal how quickly fear and
politics can overwhelm rational public health responses.
"The
greatest danger aboard the Hondius may not be that this virus becomes
the next pandemic. It is that, after covid-19 exposed the catastrophic
costs of delay, denial and disjointed global action, the world still
appears dangerously willing to repeat the same mistakes."
No comments:
Post a Comment